i want to do a little ✨ ama about atproto ✨ in this thread. no question is too simple
if you’ve been curious about atproto but don’t know much (anything?) about it, ask any question and i’ll try to explain it in my own words.
(+ would love to hear from friends who aren’t very active on bsky)
atproto has one big idea: apps should be lenses rather than boxes
this idea is still unknown to majority of internet users. even to the majority of web developers
we’re still at a phase where, if you explain it to someone, you can literally see it clicking for them in real time
i want to spread the word about atproto. if you’re running a podcast, i’d be happy to hop in to talk about it. i understand it decently well and can explain it without much jargon. it’s one of the most interesting developments in the last 30 years of web, and i can defend that. please dm to set up!
ugh web is so complicated. that certificate authority looks quite centralized to me. and that CDN might end up expensive to run at scale. and do we really need another standard? just use email
the thing that annoys me the most about the “we’d never do things like train our AI on your content” messaging is that it’s completely misleading
if anything, bluesky makes it easy for ANYONE to train AI on your content. it fights monopolies by democratizing access to public data, not by abstaining
and then [okay this is for old people; bear with me] remember the failed promise of web 2.0 with pipes and services talking to each other. this was fragile because each service can break the entire thing and has to expose API. here there's no API because we just aggregate from files. RSS was right
i was just rereading atproto.com/articles/atp... and it's so fantastically written. granted, maybe not for every audience, but for me it's a classic
for example of interop benefit, look how @leaflet.pub, @pckt.blog and @offprint.app teamed up to use the same data format so subscriptions from one app work in all apps. and then @bsky.app added a fancy link card when a post links to data in that format
competition AND cooperation now possible
i use bluesky because it’s the closest thing to what i want on the unchangeable axis (topology) and the topology makes all other things potentially changeable over time
there is a pathway to the right thing from here. there’s no pathway to the right thing from twitter or threads or whatever
if you write an insightful blog post on a specific enough topic, and people link to it, you have a real chance at influencing everyone's llm output in a year or so. it's a bit wild
@alexbenzer.com @samuel.fm pls fix this — this is how bluesky greeted me on an old computer that doesn't know i moved hosting. it is super confusing it's trying to get me to sign into my old PDS and i suspect this would again break the app
just detect that i moved hosting and don't show it
i'll be on a podcast talking about atproto this friday!
i think atproto pilled devs are much more forgiving towards bluesky as an app and give it a lot of leeway because they know apps don’t have the final say. so we kind of already live in a prefect app that doesn’t exist yet
whereas non atproto pilled devs see app as the final product. and bounce
new @shoptalkshow.com episode about atproto with me is out!
again i don’t quite understand this because mathematics is fundamental.
the platonic voice in me says let’s see the undiscovered country! no one is poorer for having skipped a few thousand years of manual effort.
if there are infinite fundamentals let’s see a whole multiverse of math. why not?
the urge to fix everything incorrectly
it would be nice to have a blogged version of this. i think protocol devs shot themselves in the foot a little by calling it an AppView. "AppViews are expensive to run" sounds AppView-specific. whereas it's really "a backend for millions of users is expensive to run", which you just don't have to do
wrote some thoughts on turbopack github.com/vercel/next....
and like oh, is that a problem for your users? maybe you should spend less effort courting users who are fundamentally opposed to the shape of the system you’re trying to build
bluesky is in this weird intersection of
- text microblogging app which is slowly losing relevance as a format
- kind of a poisoned brand for ppl outside
- most “the web” thing there is. beautiful invention
- app still looking for its purpose beyond protocol demo
- real communities
this is the face of your website btw. infinite generic boomer slop with occasional article about musk or trump
maybe fixing the default algorithm could be a priority several years in? might be more effective at getting people to actually *want* to join